In June 2025, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposed repealing all greenhouse gas emissions limits for fossil-fuel-fired power plants. In the alternative, EPA proposed to repeal the emissions guidelines for existing fossil-fuel-fired steam generating units, the carbon-capture-and-storage-based (CCS-based) standards for coal-fired steam-generating units undertaking a large modification, and the CCS-based standards for new base load stationary combustion turbines.
In our comment letter, we explain that the Proposed Rule misstates the law and the facts around regulating greenhouse gas emissions from power plants. Specifically, we explain that:
- EPA should withdraw its primary proposal because it relies on a misunderstanding of EPA’s legal authority to regulate emissions from fossil-fuel-fired power plants. The Clean Air Act does not require EPA to make a greenhouse-gas-specific significant contribution before the agency may regulate emissions of these pollutants from the power sector. Under Section 111, this finding is made only once, at the time the source is listed, and is made for the source category as a whole.
- Greenhouse gas emissions from fossil-fuel-fired power plants contribute significantly to dangerous air pollution, as demonstrated by EPA’s past practice of making significance determinations for sources that contribute far smaller shares to dangerous air pollution, and by the best available evidence which shows that greenhouse gas emissions from the power sector cause significant health and welfare damages. EPA may not get around this reality by considering policy implications of setting standards within its significance analysis, and its application of these considerations is arbitrary and one-sided.
- EPA should withdraw its alternative proposal because it is legally unsound and unsupported by the facts. EPA’s analysis inaccurately assesses the costs of carbon capture and storage, fails to justify its conclusion that such technology is not “adequately demonstrated,” and ignores the agency’s obligation to consider alternatives other than a full repeal of emission limits.
- EPA’s regulatory analysis is critically flawed. The agency fails to explain its own findings that the costs of the Proposed Rule well exceed the benefits, does not update the regulatory baseline to reflect significant regulatory and market changes, ignores the distributional and climate effects of the rule, and improperly uses outdated discount rates.
In addition to this letter, Policy Integrity also filed a joint comment highlighting EPA’s failure to consider the social cost of greenhouse gases in its proposed rule.



