Menu

Recent Projects

Comments to the Environmental Protection Agency on Its Repeal of Greenhouse Gas Emission Standards for Power Plants

In September 2026, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) took two actions to repeal greenhouse gas emission standards for power plants. The first action finalized the repeal of key greenhouse gas standards for power plants because EPA changed its position regarding the standards’ technical feasibility and cost reasonableness.

In the second action, EPA proposed to repeal all remaining greenhouse gas emission standards for fossil-fuel-fired power plants. EPA argues that Section 111 of the Clean Air Act does not authorize EPA to prescribe emission standards to address global climate change. EPA attempts to support this position by asserting that Section 111 must be interpreted to address only local or regional air pollution, that regulating greenhouse gas emissions from power plants implicates the major questions doctrine, and that regulating these emissions is futile because global climate change is such a large problem.

In our comments on EPA’s proposal, we offered the following insights:

  • EPA’s proposal relies on a novel and incorrect interpretation of the Clean Air Act. Statutory text, legislative context, and regulatory history all affirm EPA’s authority to use Section 111 to address global climate change and other air pollution problems that endanger public health or welfare through means other than local or regional exposure. Existing statutory constraints allow the agency to avoid regulating de minimis emissions without adopting EPA’s new interpretation—as evidenced by the agency’s longstanding practice.
  • Contrary to EPA’s assertions, the major questions doctrine does not preclude EPA from regulating greenhouse gas emissions under Section 111. The Supreme Court has effectively held that the major questions doctrine does not prohibit such regulation. And because such regulation was neither unprecedented nor transformed EPA’s regulatory authority, it did not trigger the major questions doctrine when EPA began to regulate greenhouse gas emissions under Section 111.
  • EPA’s finding that it is futile to regulate power plants’ greenhouse gas emissions is arbitrary and erroneous. EPA departs without adequate justification from its long-standing use of social cost of greenhouse gases, a peer-reviewed, state-of-the-art tool to measure climate change damages. EPA proposes to measure welfare effects, but discusses only the physical effects of sea level rise and global temperature that would inform actual welfare effects. EPA also ignores other climate change impacts and relies on fundamentally flawed underestimates of sea level rise and temperature change effects from power sector emissions. EPA inappropriately trivializes the climate benefits of Section 111 regulations by comparing them to global baselines, but its own approach to assessing the 2026 Proposal’s cost savings demonstrates the fallacy of that approach.
  • Power plant greenhouse gas emissions clearly contribute significantly to air pollution that endangers public health or welfare. Using EPA’s own models for estimating climate change damages and projections of power sector emissions, greenhouse gas emissions from the power sector will cause over $20 trillion in damages. The U.S. power sector’s unregulated emissions could also cause over 100,000 additional U.S. mortalities by 2200. And even these substantial figures are likely underestimates because these models do not comprehensively capture all important effects of climate change. For over five decades, EPA has recognized much smaller shares of large pollution problems to merit regulation under Section 111.
  • EPA fails to consider important effects of its proposal. EPA should analyze the effects of its proposed action under possible future scenarios, including the addition of new coal generation and the vacatur of EPA’s partial repeal of the Carbon Pollution Standards. When doing so, EPA should quantify and monetize all significant impacts, including the climate costs and the costs of increased co-pollutant emissions that result.

Given these fundamental legal and factual flaws, we recommend that EPA withdraw its proposed rule. Additional research on EPA’s action to repeal greenhouse gas emission limits for power plants is available here.