In June 2026, the New Jersey Business Improvement Association (NJBIA) launched a campaign to “Rethink RGGI,” calling for New Jersey to suspend its participation in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and replace it with a $7 flat fee on power plant greenhouse gas emissions. In the press release announcing this campaign launch, NJBIA cited a paper by Tabors Caramanis Rudkevich Inc., a consulting firm. According to the NJBIA’s press release, this paper showed that its “solution” would, beginning in 2027, yield direct consumer savings of $279 million on NJ energy bills annually, almost 5 million fewer short tons of carbon dioxide emissions annually, and $135 million in state allowance revenue annually.
The paper and its results are misleading for five reasons:
- The paper excludes RGGI states outside of PJM, making it impossible to draw conclusions about global greenhouse gas emissions impacts.
- The paper only considers the short-run effects of RGGI (i.e., changes in the use of existing power plants) and not the long-run effects (i.e., changes in investment in new power plants).
- The paper looks at how changes in compliance costs borne by power plants could translate into savings for consumers but ignores how power plants would also reap substantial profits by not participating in RGGI.
- States participating in RGGI receive significant revenue from the sale of allowances, which enable states to reduce power bills and fund clean energy programs. This paper fails to account for the reduced revenues and the social benefits these sales provide.
- Although the paper makes reference to a “Fixed Price Proposal,” it does not propose any specific policy, but simply models a world in which the RGGI allowance price is fixed at $7 for New Jersey without specifying how such a fixed price would be accomplished. Specifics matter; they will affect costs and emissions across RGGI states, yet the paper does not consider the consequences of various possible policy designs.
