Contrary to the suggestion that the 2023 update to the Office of Management and Budget’s (OMB’s) Circular A-4 “ignored [a] consensus” favoring higher discount rates (Blomquist 2025), the positions of the nine peer reviewers on the 2023 update were much more nuanced and diverse. In fact, they featured significant support for the 2023 update, including a majority that supported a central value of 2% or lower as the risk-free discount rate, and no calls for retaining the 7% capital-based rate. Moreover, public comments—including from noted experts on the discount rate and Nobel laureates—overwhelmingly supported the update. OMB also made several substantive changes in the final version of the updated guidance to further respond to the feedback from peer reviewers. Given the multitude of expert perspectives on discounting, there is no single consensus view. Yet ironically, to the extent almost all reviews might have agreed on at least one point, it is this: virtually nobody favored the course of action now adopted by the Trump Administration, of simply retaining the twenty-year-old, outdated guidance on discounting without any updates.
Nobody Wants This: Essentially No Experts Advised Retaining Old Discount Rates
Working Paper
