Institute for Policy Integrity

Twitter @policyintegrity

What We Do

Project Updates

ACUS Accepts Policy Integrity’s Recommendation on Remand Without Vacatur

December 5, 2013

The Administrative Conference of the United States (ACUS) Committee on Judicial Review accepted a recommendation made by Policy Integrity on remand without vacatur.

Remand without vacatur is when a court returns a regulation to an agency for revision but leaves the original rule intact while revisions are pending, instead of the traditional approach of striking down the original rule entirely until a new rule can be promulgated and approved. Depending on the interests of the parties involved, remand without vacatur can be an improvement over the traditional approach for two reasons: it allows net benefits from the original rule to accrue while the new regulation is pending and it removes the antiregulatory bias that can discourage plaintiffs from challenging a rule for being too lenient.

Our recommendation on prioritizing the interest of the prevailing party was discussed at length and had support, but was ultimately defeated on a relatively close vote. ACUS adopted our recommendation to clarify the scope of the administrative record—modified to indicate that it applied only to notice-and-comment rulemaking—even though it was opposed by the committee.

We submitted our comments in November 2013 to help strengthen ACUS’s draft recommendations.

Filed under Public Comments, Transparency