Menu

Recent Projects

  • The Myth of Evenhanded Administration: Integrating Individual Heterogeneity into Benefit-Cost Analysis Cover

    The Myth of Evenhanded Administration: Integrating Individual Heterogeneity into Benefit-Cost Analysis

    Duke Law Journal

    In 2025, the Trump Administration ended longstanding efforts to determine the extent to which pollution has disproportionate impacts on different communities, including overburdened and disadvantaged communities. But, at the same time, it reaffirmed its commitment to performing benefit-cost analysis to analyze the consequences of regulations, including environmental regulations. These approaches are mutually inconsistent. A proper benefit-cost analysis simply cannot be done without considering distribution of a policy’s impacts. Often, the populations affected by government policies vary from the median in significant ways. Heterogeneity by age, race, income, and other factors is relevant to the assessment of the benefits and costs of particular policies for three principal reasons. On the benefits side, certain groups face higher levels of exposure to environmental harms and higher harms from exposure to an additional unit of pollution than does an average member of the population. Also, certain groups have higher vulnerability to particular exposures. And, on the cost side, certain groups bear higher burdens because of differences in geography, spending patterns, and other behaviors. This article provides a robust review of the scientific, epidemiological, and economic literature for each of these mechanisms, surveys what agencies have already done, and sets forth an agenda for future research.

    Read more

  • Data-Driven Environmental Policy in Times of Economic Turmoil: PlaNYC’s Successful Initiative To Clean Up the Heating Oil Sector Cover

    Data-Driven Environmental Policy in Times of Economic Turmoil: PlaNYC’s Successful Initiative To Clean Up the Heating Oil Sector

    Working Paper

    After the adoption of PlaNYC in April 2007, New York City was able to change city and state laws to clean up the heating oil sector, despite significant economic uncertainty during Great Recession that occurred from late 2007 to mid-2009. The success of what became known as the Clean Heat campaign was enabled by a data-driven analysis of health benefits and economic costs undertaken by academics, agencies, and environmental groups, which informed extensive stakeholder engagement in the legislative and regulatory arenas and was facilitated by the Bloomberg Administration’s measure-then-management governing philosophy. 

    Read more

  • A Thumb on the Scale Cover

    A Thumb on the Scale

    EPA’s Arbitrary Decision To Stop Valuing Pollution Health Costs

    Soot and smog pollution cause early deaths, asthma attacks, emergency room visits, neurological damage, and other harmful health effects. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has refined its understanding of these impacts over decades to better inform the public as well as its own decisionmaking. Yet in January 2026 EPA abruptly decided to reject its extraordinarily well-established estimates of human health impacts from pollution. In this report, we explain why EPA’s omission of well-understood and well-established estimates of pollution impacts is arbitrary and capricious. EPA should return to its longstanding approach of quantifying and monetizing the harms of soot and smog.

    Read more

  • Comments to the Environmental Protection Agency on Its Repeal of Greenhouse Gas Emission Standards for Power Plants

    In September 2026, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) took two actions to repeal greenhouse gas emission standards for power plants. The first action finalized the repeal of key greenhouse gas standards for power plants because EPA changed its position regarding the standards’ technical feasibility and cost reasonableness. In the second action, EPA proposed to repeal all remaining greenhouse gas emission standards for fossil-fuel-fired power plants. In our comments on EPA’s proposal, we offer insights on fundamental legal and factual flaws in EPA’s proposed and recommend that EPA withdraw it.

    Read more

  • Comments to the New York Public Service Commission on Energy Reliability Need in New York City

    In December 2025, the New York Public Service Commission opened a proceeding to address looming reliability shortfalls on New York City’s electric grid. The Public Service Commission directed Con Edison, the electric distribution utility serving New York City, to develop a plan to meet the need using only clean and non-emitting solutions. In July 2026, after receiving and evaluating a variety of proposals submitted in response to a Request for Information (RFI), Con Edison filed its Reliability Contingency Plan. Policy Integrity filed comments on the Reliability Contingency Plan. Con Edison’s explanation for its choices should include a full analysis of the benefits and costs of the the proposal and alternatives that were fully evaluated, or an explanation for why no alternatives were fully evaluated.

    Read more

  • Fact Sheet: Flaws in EPA’s Repeal of Greenhouse Gas Standards for Power Plants

    In this fact sheet, we lay out legal precedent and scientific and economic evidence that justify U.S. climate regulations, contrary to arguments made by the Environmental Protection Agency in a recent repeal of key limits on greenhouse gas emissions from the power sector and a proposed rule asserting the agency does not have authority to regulate these emissions.

    Read more

  • Amicus Brief for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit on the Environmental Protection Agency’s 2026 Rollback of Hydrofluorocarbon Restrictions

    In 2023, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency issued a rule under the American Innovation and Manufacturing (AIM) Act restricting the use of certain hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs). HFCs are potent greenhouse gases used in refrigeration and other proccesses. In May 2026, EPA issued a rule relaxing some of those restrictions. Policy Integrity submitted an amicus brief in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit supporting the petitioners challenging the 2026 rule. Our brief argues that EPA’s failure to meaningfully consider the Final Rule’s climate impacts violates the AIM Act and is arbitrary and capricious. It also argues that EPA made the rule effective far sooner than the AIM Act allows.

    Read more

  • Regulatory Speed and the Litigation Clock Cover

    Regulatory Speed and the Litigation Clock

    Part of the Major Rules in the Courts Series

    An administration must prioritize speed if it wants to control the defense of its own regulations in court. Less than a quarter of challenged rules finalized during the first Trump Administration or Biden Administration finished litigation during the administration that issued the rule. This piece presents original analysis on the timing of regulatory litigation and discusses its implications for agency rulemaking and prioritization.

    Read more

  • Critique of a RGGI Alternative for New Jersey Cover

    Critique of a RGGI Alternative for New Jersey

    A Fixed $7 Fee Could Create Significant Consequences

    In June 2026, the New Jersey Business Improvement Association (NJBIA) launched a campaign to “Rethink RGGI,” calling for New Jersey to suspend its participation in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and replace it with a $7 flat fee on power plant greenhouse gas emissions. In the press release announcing this campaign launch, NJBIA cited a paper by Tabors Caramanis Rudkevich Inc., a consulting firm. According to the NJBIA’s press release, this paper showed that its “solution” would, beginning in 2027, yield direct consumer savings of $279 million on NJ energy bills annually, almost 5 million fewer short tons of carbon dioxide emissions annually, and $135 million in state allowance revenue annually. The paper and its results are misleading for five reasons.

    Read more

  • Comments to the Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement and the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management on Their Proposed Rollback of Arctic Offshore Drilling Regulations

    The Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement and the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (collectively, the Joint Bureaus) developed this Proposed Rule in response to Executive Order 14,514 and federal agencies’ subsequent review of regulations affecting domestic energy production. The Proposed Rule expands the definition of the Arctic Outer Continental Shelf, permits the use of subsea isolation devices instead of nearby relief rigs for oil spill management, and allows leaseholders to drill throughout the entire open-water season. The Joint Bureaus do not adequately quantify the forgone benefits of the preexisting, more environmentally protective leasing program and overestimate the cost savings of the Proposed Rule, skewing their analysis. Policy Integrity submitted a comment letter regarding the Joint Bureaus’ Proposed Rule that raises several criticisms. 

    Read more